The housing market slowdown deepened in October, with the number of homes going under contract falling nearly 17% from a year earlier. Zillow’s chief economist thinks November will be even weaker. Mischa Fisher says the “worst of it” is likely to land this month before the slowdown eases into the new year, and he still sees “deals to be had” for buyers who can afford to move, according to Moneywise.
The chill is showing up well beyond Zillow’s numbers. Previously occupied home sales fell last month to their slowest annual pace in more than 16 years, while the average 30-year mortgage rate has stayed above 7% and could remain elevated for some time.
Also read: Goldman Sachs has a new warning for the housing market for 2027
Fisher’s view is that the worst of the slowdown creates its own opportunity. With more homes sitting on the market and fewer competing buyers, those who can secure financing may find conditions more favorable than they have been in years.
Why November could mark the bottom
Zillow’s latest market report showed that newly pending listings are down nearly 17% from a year ago, the steepest annual fall since August 2023. These are homes that have gone under contract but haven’t closed yet, so the number gives an early peek at where sales are likely headed.
October was also the slowest October for pending sales since 2018, and existing-home sales fell nearly 10% from a year earlier. “November is shaping up to have an even larger contraction,” Fisher said. “I expect the pace of the slowdown to ease into the new year.”
Redfin is seeing the same thing. Its figures show home sales fell from the previous month in October for the first time in three years, while the median sale price dipped slightly year over year, its first annual decline since May 2023. Redfin’s Dana Anderson put it this way: “Home sales fell as mortgage rates surpassed 7%, but flattening prices could bring buyers a bit of relief”.
Borrowing costs are the main culprit. Mortgage rates have climbed since late February, when the U.S. war with Iran pushed up oil prices and inflation, and the 30-year average reached 7.4% in early October, its highest level in nearly three years. That came after rates had briefly dipped to 5.98% in late February, the lowest since late 2022.
Higher payments are squeezing buyers
Buyers are paying a lot more each month. Zillow estimates the typical mortgage payment reached $2,004 in October, up nearly 13% from a year earlier, even with a 20% down payment. That figure does not include taxes or insurance.
The jump from September alone was the biggest one-month increase in four years. Once taxes, insurance and maintenance are added in, a median-income household would now spend more than 40% of its income on the payment, up from roughly 39% a year ago.
There has been a little relief lately. Freddie Mac’s average 30-year rate fell to roughly 7.11% on Nov. 12, its fourth straight weekly decline, though it is still well above 6.2% a year ago. On a $400,000 loan, that still means paying roughly $300 more a month than when rates were just under 6%. Persistent inflation has also raised the odds of a Federal Reserve rate hike at its December meeting.
That squeeze has made renting look more appealing. Zillow estimates buying a typical single-family home now takes $14,408 more in annual income than renting one. “For a growing number of households, renting a house is a legitimate financial strategy,” said Zillow economist Kara Ng. Zillow figures a buyer would need to stay put for about 7.8 years before owning beats renting.
MoMo Productions / Getty Images
Buyers finally have room to negotiate
There were slightly more homes on the market than a year earlier, giving buyers room to be choosier. Fisher said buyers “have more to choose from in most markets than they’ve had in years,” which can mean less risk of a bidding war and more room to ask a seller to fix a leaky roof or accept an inspection contingency, according to Moneywise.
The shift is visible across the country. Only 3 of the 50 largest U.S. metros are now seller’s markets, while 41 favor buyers. “That’s tied for the fewest in records dating back to 2016,” Anderson said of the seller’s markets. Redfin’s median monthly payment has also eased to a six-week low.
More Mortgage Rates and Housing Market:
- Fannie Mae updates its mortgage rate predictions for 2027
- Jeff Bezos has a blunt answer for why housing is so expensive
Redfin suggests buyers consider offering below the asking price and pushing for help with closing costs, repairs or a mortgage-rate buydown. Still, economist Chen Zhao offered a reality check: “It’s a buyer’s market, but not many people can afford to buy.”
A good agent can help you judge an offer against recent sales nearby. A seller whose home has sat on the market for months may be more willing to cut the price or chip in on closing costs.
Get the financing right before you bid
It pays to shop around for a loan. Freddie Mac’s research found that borrowers may need up to five quotes to land the best deal. And in 2022, people who compared offers shaved a fraction of a percentage point off their rate on average. Don’t ignore the fees, either. Closing costs typically run from 2% to 5% of the loan and can also outweigh a small gap in rates.
Do not count on a big drop in rates while you wait. Housing economists no longer expect rates to fall below 6% anytime soon, and a return below 7% looks very unlikely. “Persistent inflation and the possibility of further Federal Reserve tightening will likely limit any significant decline,” said finance professor Sean Salter.
That matters because housing activity tends to pick up when 30-year rates fall below about 6.64% and weaken as they approach 7%, based on HousingWire’s tracking. Until rates move, buyers who keep their down payment in an interest-bearing account and their financing lined up will be best placed to grab the deals Fisher expects.
Related: HELOC balances just hit a milestone not seen in decades






