IBM shares crashed toward their worst single trading day in nearly four decades on Tuesday, July 14, after CEO Arvind Krishna told investors the company’s second quarter fell short of what Wall Street expected.
Within hours of that warning, one bank cut its price target and told clients to consider buying a basket of IBM’s rivals instead. Another bank raised its target that same morning.
That split reaction is the real story here, and it says more about what actually went wrong than the stock chart does.
IBM shares fell as much as 23% in premarket trading, putting the stock on pace for its steepest one-day drop since Black Monday in October 1987, according to CNN.
The company said preliminary second-quarter revenue came in at $17.2 billion, below the $17.85 billion analysts had expected, with adjusted earnings of $2.93 a share missing the $3.01 consensus, according to CNBC.
IBM’s mainframe wasn’t the problem
Investors initially assumed IBM’s newest mainframe, the z17, was struggling to find buyers. That’s not quite what happened.
In a letter to investors posted on IBM’s newsroom, Krishna said clients redirected their quarterly capital budgets in late June toward servers, storage, and memory instead, rushing to lock in supply-constrained hardware before prices climb further.
Infrastructure revenue fell 7% as a result, while software growth of 5% and flat consulting revenue couldn’t offset the gap.
That timing detail matters. The memory shortage driving this behavior traces back to Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron shifting production capacity toward the specialized chips that power AI data centers, leaving standard enterprise memory effectively sold out, as CNN reported.
IBM’s own clients are getting squeezed by the same AI buildout that’s supposed to be their growth catalyst.
Alex Wong / Getty Images
Rivals with no connection to IBM’s supply chain got dragged down anyway
The selloff didn’t stay contained to IBM. ServiceNow (NOW) fell nearly 7%, Salesforce (CRM) lost 5%, and Accenture (ACN) and Cognizant Technology Solutions (CTSH) dropped 8% and 7%, according to a Seeking Alpha report.
None of those companies share IBM’s mainframe exposure or its z17supply chain problem.
What they share is a client base now reprioritizing hardware over software contracts, and investors treated that as reason enough to sell first and ask questions later.
Related: IBM just answered a $5 billion cybersecurity question
Beyond the immediate software drop, several key market indicators highlight the scale of Tuesday’s pressure:
- Adobe (ADBE), Workday (WDAY), HubSpot (HUBS), Datadog (DDOG), and Microsoft all fell 3% or more in sympathy trading, despite none of them reporting results that morning, according to Seeking Alpha.
- IBM’s GAAP earnings per share came in at $2.27, down 2% year over year, with pretax margin contracting 90 basis points, according to IBM’s investor letter.
- The stock’s premarket slide erased tens of billions of dollars in market value in a matter of hours, a scale TheStreet flagged as one of the day’s biggest single-stock movers.
Wall Street’s price targets don’t agree with the panic
If this were a straightforward demand collapse, analysts would be lining up to cut targets in unison. They aren’t.
HSBC downgraded IBM to Reduce and slashed its target to $191 from $231, arguing clients could build a “synthetic IBM” from SAP, Accenture, HP, and IonQ shares for less money and better exposure, according to Investing.com.
Oppenheimer went the opposite direction the same morning, raising its target to $350 from $320, while Morgan Stanley lifted its target to $293 from $267, according to Tipranks.
That divergence suggests most of the Street sees this as a timing problem tied to one volatile quarter, not a structural break in IBM’s software business. Red Hat, IBM’s fastest-growing unit, wasn’t even flagged as a source of weakness.
More IBM:
- IBM stock surged again: The reason sounds like sci-fi
- IBM’s latest Wall Street call hides bigger shift
- IBM stock just got powerful new price target from Wall Street
Memory shortage evolves into an enterprise tech story
IBM’s warning is a preview of something bigger than one company’s mainframe cycle.
When memory and server prices rise fast enough, corporate buyers start pulling forward hardware purchases at the expense of software renewals and consulting engagements.
That reallocation can hit any vendor whose revenue depends on the same IT budgets.
Investors should watch IBM’s full earnings call on July 22 for whether Krishna can quantify how much of the shortfall was delayed rather than lost, and whether other enterprise software and consulting names report the same late-June spending shift when their turns come.
If the pattern repeats across the sector, Tuesday’s selloff won’t have been an overreaction. It will have been early.
Related: IBM’s latest Wall Street call hides bigger shift
